“RELAX, THE LITURGY WILL TAKE CARE OF ITSELF!” said the faithful elder at the end of the service.
Suddenly I realized the anxiety I had been feeling about church attendance, more specifically a precipitous drop in church attendance, had begun to affect my attitude and behavior in worship. As a worship leader, this change apparently had become palpable to members in the pew and had serious ramifications, not least of which could be the further alienation of the faithful remnant, not to mention the Holy Spirit. Yet it wasn’t as if my concerns weren’t well motivated. God knows, there has been cause enough to be concerned in both church and culture in our time.
Following the prophetic witness of the church in our nation-wide 2003 General Convention, attendance in my little parish around the corner in a small
Combining this culture-war battle in the national church with a bold and outright advocacy from the local pulpit on behalf of social justice for all members of Christ’s body, the church - in a congregation that demographically tended slightly to the conservative side of things - was risky to say the least. Compounding this dynamic for destruction with a long-term pastorate (by 2006 18 years in duration) that has not been a walk in the park for any number of reasons, left my rectorship especially vulnerable. Nothing like a good (bad) controversy and a few scores to settle to get the congregation riled up . . .
The last three years in a word, have been exacting in time, energy and faith. The fact that I’m still standing is a tribute either to German obstinancy or English sensibility (both gene sets at work in my personality), or to a goodly measure of common-sense and decency exercised by my lay leadership. Usually, the short-term satisfaction in any major church crisis, as in business, is to lob off the head of the leader rather address systemic issues. It's easier and appears decisive.
Our parish history throughout the twentieth century in fact is littered with unsuccessful ministries involving clergy and laity. When I arrived in the fall of 1988, respect for the clergy and the parish’s reputation in the eyes of outsiders were low and well-deserved. Our concept of parish health was to celebrate interims (you know, the supply clergy between pastorates, the ones with all the smiles and none of the guts for meaningful ministry). I would hope we’ve done something about this in my time, and it would seem we have, although slow developing to be sure but progress nonetheless.
These years later, I am deeply grateful and proud of a turnaround in the culture of the parish. We are addressing the real issues of our time, the ones that speak directly to our local situation. We even have a strategic plan in place, the first such document in our 164-year history. Our focus is increasingly on ministries and mission of compassion and care for others, and not so much as before on our "Episcopalian" pride of place in public square or our individual purposes in private prayer. The tacit motto of former generations - "Manners maketh the man" - has given way to a motto unanimously affirmed by the current leadership - "To grow in God's image, and to spread Christ's kingdom, through the power of the Holy Spirit."
An ironic and future positive outcome of the recent 2003 separating of ways owing to theological and cultural differences among the membership (alluded to earlier) has been that a certain, non-traditional element of the evangelical right, our perceived growth edge in recent years, has gone from us as well. Turns out they had every bit as much pride and self-righteousness in religion as "God's frozen chosen" ever did. As soon as the church affirmed social justice for faithful worshippers of alternative lifestyles, they screamed indignantly and quoted the Bible, chapter and verse, as if they had exclusive knowledge, understanding and wisdom in reading and interpreting God's will in the 21st century. Sometimes I wish I had their certainty of conviction, but then I used to wish I could walk on water, restore sight to the blind, hearing to the deaf, ambulation to the lame, cast out demons and raise the dead.
All of which leaves us here in the parish without extremes, neither the old Episcopalians so full of themselves for simply being themselves nor the mistakenly perceived new growth which turned out to be intent on remaking the Episcopal Church in the image of whatever Methodist or Baptist or non-denominational church of their childhoods. We centrists are left alone in the center of things as it probably should have been all along, a spiritual remnant at the still small center of heavenly things that is God’s life in this world.
What lies ahead in this current spirit of parish leadership is an adventure that promises good things, wholesome and holy things well worth our living out together. Such things are premised in a gracious knowing that one indeed should “relax, (for) the liturgy will take care itself.” A rather pleasant Anglican thought that, at least for those of us who have not lost our confidence and trust in the Mysterious Center that holds this rapidly turning world of ours together.
We cannot control or much affect what is happening elsewhere. Yet we can do this much in our own parish lives, namely be faithful and trust the liturgy to work its wonders of grace. This spirit of obedient centeredness, so counter to today's rebellious assertion of self above and beyond all things, may be the real way forward for the church. The words of our ancient faith would suggest as much. "The Lord is in His holy temple, let all the earth keep silence before Him!" "Be still and know that I am God!” Perhaps it's time to deliberately and intentionally rachet down the stress and noise of our several anxieties, the clamor to be seen and heard, and be at peace as the risen Lord bids His disciples in this Easter season.
